Wednesday, November 29, 2023

Bell's theorem is for ANY wave, not specifically for quantum mechanics

We have earlier in this blog claimed that Bell's theorem essentially states a very obvious fact that if you make a wave function to "collapse", the collapse destroys precious information, and you cannot reproduce the same interference pattern that you could produce with an "unharmed" wave.


Today we realized that actually this is true for any wave, also for classical waves. Consider the double-slit experiment. We can treat the laser beam as a classical electromagnetic wave, or alternatively, a probability amplitude wave of quantum mechanics (using the Feynman terminology).

If we disturb the wave, the interference pattern on the screen changes. A "collapse" of the wave is a drastic operation on an electromagnetic wave. It is like using a converter to transform an analog (real number) signal to a binary number 0 or 1.

A "hidden variable" hypothesis typically is incompatible with the hypothesis that we are dealing with a simple, undisturbed wave.


Non-locality


Bell's theorem is often interpreted as showing that quantum mechanics is "nonlocal". There is a "spooky action at a distance", to paraphrase Albert Einstein.

In this blog we do not believe in any spooky action at a distance. Rather, we believe that the wave function can only "collapse" inside the head of a single observer. Any measurement result made by any measuring apparatus is transmitted as a probability amplitude wave into the head of the observer, where the final collapse happens. It is like the double-slit experiment where the screen is placed inside the head of the single observer.

No comments:

Post a Comment